You are here
Internet, Censorship and Political Participation in China
Internet, Censorship and Political Participation in China
Monday, 18 October 2010
Barnard Professor of Political Science Xiaobo Lü, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism Professor and Founder of the China Digital Times Xiao Qiang, and Barnard Associate Professor of Sociology Guobin Yang convened to participate in a panel discussion moderated by Columbia Journalism School Professor Howard French. They gathered to discuss how the Internet manifests among China’s current 420 million Internet users, especially in terms of the interplay between the government and China’s citizens via online discourse. Despite government regulation, Lü argued that the Internet is a powerful tool for political change because it generates discussion about government policy among the growing number of Internet users, giving citizens the opportunity to express their opinions and pressurizing the government toward policy change.
Lü began the discussion by explaining how the Chinese government provides public goods while controlling coordination goods, such as human rights, free press, access to higher education, and the Internet. Because of restrictions on the latter, China’s netizens, over one-quarter of those who are from rural areas, use the Internet primarily for entertainment, online news, instant messaging, and online games. But Lü then pointed out that in a non-democratic system, the power of the Internet is in fact enhanced. Ironically, 88 percent of Chinese netizens have written blogs to express opinions, while only 32 percent of users have done so within America’s free speech borders.
Xiao, who spends his time in Chinese cyberspace because he cannot return to China, believes that “censorship is a violence against humans.” He employed the metaphors of “playing field” and “battlefield” to describe China’s online environment. Users play on entertainment websites, but they are also pushing against the government by authoring blogs and cartooning. Xiao also feels that the Internet is becoming “more a door than a war. At least the door is opening, and once the door is open it is very hard to close. The Internet gives me hope for more political change.” Lü remarked that ultimately technology reigns outside of the reaches of government regulations because it is such a vast entity in itself. It is this that gives hope for political change down the road.
Yang agreed with Xiao’s idea that the Chinese government uses the Internet as a safety valve to test out citizen opinions. Yang believes the power of the Internet is growing, not because of loosening political control, but rather because of the persistence of shocking forms of political injustice. Migrant groups work together to protest through the Internet, activism is seeping into the Twitter realm, and Chinese rights consciousness is growing.
Lü, Xiao, and Yang see the Internet as a power shifting force. Lü noted a time when the government invited three netizen delegates to a local government council meeting— an occurrence that he felt was simply “amazing.” French pointed out that the government knows it needs to use the Internet as an economically indispensible tool to gauge citizen opinions.
At intermission, the audience turned its attention to United States Ambassador to China Jon Huntsman on live webcast from Beijing as part of the National Committee on United States-China Relations’ CHINA Town Hall. He contributed to the Internet discussion, stressing that “bloggers are the ones pushing the envelope,” and that China and the USA need passionate next generations to keep global communication open and flowing.
APEC Study Center at Columbia University
Columbia University, 3022 Broadway
2M-9 Uris Hall
New York, NY 10027-7004
The Curl Ideas to wrap your mind around
Henry Kravis Increases Gift to $125 Million, Adding to Manhattanville Fundraising Momentum
Henry Kravis ’69 is celebrating Columbia Business School’s Centennial anniversary and contributing to the School’s future by generously increasing his gift to $125 million, up from $100 million, to help fund the new Manhattanville Campus.Read More
Inaugural Centennial Showcase in New York Draws Hundreds of Attendees
Over 400 alumni and friends of the School gathered on Wednesday, September 16, to commemorate the School's Centennial, reflect on past achievements, and hear more about what's to come.Read More
Columbia Business School Partners with Industry to Create New Immersion Experience for Students
Immersion Seminar opportunity allows students to discuss real-world challenges and strategy with top practitioners across a range of industries.Read More
Fast Forward: Shazi Visram '04
As part of the School's Centennial celebration, alumni leaders offer predictions about the future in business and beyond.Read More
Why Shadow Banking in China Matters
When official avenues of financing are blocked off, companies have little recourse but to turn to shadow lenders. This excerpt from a new Chazen Institute white paper explains why.Read More
In Central America, Investing for a Greater Good
While a student at Columbia Business School, Arnoldo Villafuerte ’72 learned about and came to believe in the strong impact of private investment not just on the economy but on the social fabric of a community.Read More
Classes Kick Off Amid Centennial Excitement
Both the Class of 2016 and the Class of 2017 — known collectively as the Centennial classes — plan to make the most of their time on campus during the School's landmark anniversary.Read More
50 Shades of Green
How cultural differences between developed and emerging markets help – or hurt – the push for environmentally friendly policiesRead More
The First Alumni Club
Nearly 40 years ago, alumni in the New York metropolitan area came together to build what would become a cornerstone of the Columbia Business School community: the first alumni club.Read More