New York City Teaching Fellows

Faced with a hiring freeze, how should the New York City Department of Education deal with graduates of the New York City Teaching Fellows program?

Erin McMahon  | Spring 2021
Print this page

Tamer Center for Social Enterprise

Launched in 2000, the New York City Teaching Fellows (NYCTF) program was conceived to attract well educated, highly motivated recruits to teach in the city’s underserved public schools. Part of a wider movement of alternative certification for teachers, the NYCTF program entailed a highly selective recruitment process, a seven-week training program, student teaching at summer schools, followed by enrollment in a master’s program in education once placed in a teaching position—with a majority of the costs paid for by the DOE. While many in the DOE believed the program was effectively placing talented teachers in underserved schools, the program faced a variety of headwinds, including pushback from the city’s teachers’ union and disappointing data about retention rates for NYCTF participants once they were placed in city schools. In 2009, the fate of the program was further challenged by a hiring freeze which left the DOE in the difficult position of having recruited and trained teachers eager to teach—and no schools able to hire them. After discussing the history of NYCTF, this case asks students to consider how to best address the hiring freeze to serve NYC schools, students, dissatisfied teaching fellows who could not find jobs, and the principals who could not hire them.

Case ID: 210414

Buy select cases through The Case Centre,  Ivey Publishing and Harvard Business Publishing.

Contact us by e-mail at Columbia CaseWorks or 212-853-8585.