Abstract

An unanswered question in the debate on public sector inefficiency is whether reforms other than government divestiture can effectively substitute for privatization. Using a 1981–1995 panel dataset of all public and private manufacturing establishments in Indonesia, we analyze whether public sector inefficiency is primarily due to agency-type problems or to the environment in which public sector enterprises operate, as measured by the soft budget constraint and the degree of internal and external competition. The results, obtained from fixed effects specifications, provide support for both models. Ownership matters because, for a given level of government financing or competition, public sector enterprises ("PSEs") perform worse than their private sector counterparts. The environment matters because only PSEs which received government financing or those shielded from import competition or foreign ownership performed worse than private enterprises. The results suggest that the efficiency of PSEs can be increased through privatization, through manipulation of the environment, or through a combination of both approaches.

Download PDF

Citation

Bartel, Ann, and Ann Harrison. "Ownership Versus Environment: Why Are Public Sector Firms Inefficient?" Review of Economics and Statistics 87, no. 1 (February 2005): 135-47.

Each author name for a Columbia Business School faculty member is linked to a faculty research page, which lists additional publications by that faculty member.

Each topic is linked to an index of publications on that topic.